Comparison of Asphaltene Models in Two Commercial Compositional Simulators

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Petroleum Engineering Department, National Iranian South Oil Company, Ahwaz, Iran

10.22078/jpst.2022.4746.1789

Abstract

The many challenges that engineers face during production from hydrocarbon reserviors due to asphaltene deposition show the importance of addressing this phenomenon in the management of reservoirs and adopting production policies. Simulation, as one of the most economic ways of reservoir studies could be done using various software packages. It is clear that each of these simulators has its own strengths and limitations that should be carefully examined and recognized. This study addresses the differences between the asphaltene models of two commercially used compositional simulators and the challenges thereof. It is done using a 3D sector model built on real data from one of the Iranian South oil reservoirs so that the final results resemble the reality of the reservoir. In addition, the simple scenario of natural depletion is considered for production from an undersaturated oil reservoir. The fluid model which is used in both simulators is the solid model implemented in WinProp and in-house software (PVT-Pro). Moreover, the same thermodynamic model has been deployed in both asphaltene models (PR-EOS). Different cases were run to demonstrate the extent of influencing the reservoir by how each simulator models the asphaltene phenomenon. As a result, porosity/permeability reduction, viscosity change, and wettability alteration were described in both simulators. Finally, both simulators are compared regarding whether can describe the final changes caused by asphaltene precipitation and deposition. In the end, the speed of each simulation run is also investigated.

Keywords


  1. Ghadimi M, Amani M J, Ghaedi M, Malayeri M R (2019) Modeling of formation damage due to asphaltene deposition in near wellbore region using a cylindrical compositional simulator, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering, 173: 630-639. ##
  2. Fazelipour W, Pope G A, Sepehrnoori K (2008) Development of a fully implicit, parallel, EOS compositional simulator to model asphaltene precipitation in petroleum reservoirs, SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Society of Petroleum Engineers. ##
  3. Gonzalez Abad K G (2013) Development of a compositional reservoir simulator for asphaltene precipitation based on a thermodynamically consistent model, Texas A and M University. ##
  4. Qin X (1998) Modeling asphaltene precipitation and implementation of group contribution [sic] equation of state into UTCOMP, The University of Texas at Austin. ##
  5. Nghiem L X, Kohse B F, Ali S, Doan, Q (2000) Asphaltene precipitation: phase behavior modeling and compositional simulation, SPE Asia Pacific Conference on Integrated Modelling for Asset Management. Society of Petroleum Engineers, OnePetro. ##
  6. Gruesbeck C, Collins R (1982) Entrainment and deposition of fine particles in porous media, Society of Petroleum Engineers Journal, 22, 06: 847–856. ##
  7. Darabi H (2014) Development of a Non-isothermal Compositional Reservoir Simulator to Model Asphaltene Precipitation, Flocculation, and Deposition and Remediation, the University of Texas at Austin, Doctoral Dissertation, 1-259. ##
  8. Kohse B F, Nghiem L X (2004) Modelling asphaltene precipitation and deposition in a compositional reservoir simulator, SPE/DOE Symposium on Improved Oil Recovery, Society of Petroleum Engineers. ##
  9. Wang S, Civan F (2001) Productivity decline of vertical and horizontal wells by asphaltene deposition in petroleum reservoirs, SPE International Symposium on Oilfield Chemistry, Society of Petroleum Engineers. ##
  10. Wang S, Civan F (2005b) Modeling formation damage by asphaltene deposition during primary oil recovery, Journal of Energy Resources Technology, 127, 4: 310-317. ##
  11. Kord S, Miri R, Ayatollahi S, Escrochi M (2012) Asphaltene deposition in carbonate rocks: experimental investigation and numerical simulation, Energy Fuels, 26, 10: 6186–6199. ##
  12. Akhlaq M S, Kessel D, Dornow W (1996) Separation and chemical characterization of wetting crude oil compounds, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 180, 2: 309–314. ##
  13. Crocker M, Marchin L (1988) Wettability and adsorption characteristics of crude-oil asphaltene and polar fractions, Journal of Petroleum Technology, 40, 04: 470–474. ##
  14. González G, Moreira M B (1991) The wettability of mineral surfaces containing adsorbed asphaltene, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 58, 3: 293–302. ##
  15. Leontaritis K J, Mansoori G A (1988) Asphaltene deposition: a survey of field experiences and research approaches, Journal of Petroleum science and Engineering, 1, 3: 229–239.
  16. Darabi H, Sepehrnoori K, Kalaei M H (2012) Modeling of wettability alteration due to asphaltene deposition in oil reservoirs, SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Society of Petroleum Engineers. ##
  17. Mohebbinia S (2013) Advanced equation of state modeling for compositional simulation of gas floods, The University of Texas at Austin. ##
  18. Delshad M, Pope G, Sepehrnoori K, (1996) A compositional simulator for modeling surfactant enhanced aquifer remediation, 1 formulation, Journal of Contaminant Hydrology, 23, 4: 303–327. ##
  19. Al-Qasim A, AlDawsari M A (2017) Comparison study of Asphaltene Precipitation Models using UTCOMP, CMG/GEM and ECLIPSE simulators, SPE Oil and Gas India Conference and Exhibition. ##
  20. Eclipse Technical Description (2018) Asphaltene Option, Asphaltene formation: Pre-2011 Model. ##
  21. Computer Modelling Group Ltd. (CMG), (2018) GEM User’s Guide: Resistance factor calculation option, Calgary, Canada, The user’s guide available internally in the CMG simulator. ##
  22. Abouie A, Darabi H, Sepehrnoori K (2017) Data-driven comparison between solid model and PC-SAFT for modeling asphaltene precipitation, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 45: 325–337. ##
  23. Computer Modelling Group Ltd. (CMG) (2015) WinProp User’s Guide: Advanced Phase Behaviour and fluid property simulator, Calgary, Canada. The user’s guide is available internally in the CMG simulator. ##
  24. Kohse B F, Nghiem L X (2004) Modeling Asphaltene precipitation and Deposition in a Compositional Reservoir Simulator, Fourteenth Symposium on Improved Oil Recovery, OnePetro. ##
  25. Nghiem L X, Kohse B F, Ali S, Doan Q (2000) Asphaltene precipitation: phase behavior modeling and compositional simulation, SPE Asia Pacific Conference on Integrated Modelling for Asset Management. Society of Petroleum Engineers.
  26. PVTPro Technical Description (2020.1) Asphaltene precipitation models, PC-SAFT EOS. ##
  27. Parsaniya F (2020) Modeling asphaltene precipitation using PC-SAFT EOS and its comparison with other equations in one of Iranian South West reservoirs, Journal of Oil and Gas Exploration and production, 176: 15. ##
  28. Khanifar A, Demiral B, Darman N )2011. The effect of asphaltene precipitation and control parameters on reservoir performance: a numerical approach, SPE Reservoir Characterization and Simulation Conference and Exhibition. ##
  29. Izadi S, Jafarzadegan M (2021) Numerical modelling of the effect of Asphaltene precipitation on wells’ productivity Index in one of Iranian South West fractured reservoirs, the 7th international Conference on Petroleum and Chemical Engineering. ##
  30. Mohebbinia S, Sepehrnoori K, Kazemi Nia Korrani A, T Johns R (2017) Simulation of Asphaltene precipitation during gas injection using PC-SAFT EOS, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering. ##